This place matters

This place matters

Sunday, November 11, 2012

Cold Chicken

So you know how in the first Harry Potter book, all problems could have been resolved at any point if the kids had just gone to Dumbledore? And you know how in the second Harry Potter book, all problems could have been resolved at any point if the kids had just gone to Dumbledore? And you know how in the third Harry Potter book... you get the idea.
That realization is an example of what Alfred Hitchcock once called an icebox scene - a plot element that makes no sense, only you don't realize it until you're at home pulling cold chicken out of the icebox. 
Some of my favorite icebox moments.

  •  In The Avengers, Thor's hammer has destroyed everything he has ever hit with it. Meaning that when he, sparring with Iron Man and Captain America, had no idea he wasn't, in fact, going to murder them.
  • In The Avengers, where's Loki while everyone's sitting around eating shwarma?
  • In Harry Potter, if Peter Pettigrew showed up with his own name on the Marauder's Map, even when he was in the form of Scabbers, Ron's pet rat. If the Weasley twins had been in possession of the Marauder's Map up until they gave it to Harry, then they would likely have noticed their brother Ron sharing a bed with a strange man every night.
  • On CSI, pretty much none of the technology they use to catch bad guys exists. You probably figured out that ATM cameras can't show a mole on the elbow of a person a mile away. But there's stuff even more basic. Anyone who owns a cat knows that hairs get tracked everywhere all the time, and finding a single hair at a crime scene doesn't mean jack. I mean, if I make my mom a scarf at my best friend's house in DC, and my best friend's dog sheds in it (because that's what her dog does for a living), and my mom gives the scarf to a homeless guy because she's deathly allergic to dogs and thus the scarf, then there's a chance there's a homeless dude wandering the streets of Cleveland with hairs on him from a dog in DC. That doesn't mean he murdered the dog. (Don't ask yourself why my mom didn't just wash the scarf - that's another icebox moment). So anyway, in the real world, there are going to be dozens, maybe hundreds of hairs floating around any given crime scene, and DNA testing is expensive. Even if you tested every piece of hair around the crime scene, the chances of matching it to the bad guy and then using it to hang him are... somewhat less good than TV would have us think.
  • How the hell does Marty McFly's mom not notice that her son looks exactly like that dude she hit with her car and tried to sleep with when she was in high school?
  • The X-Men leave more bodies in their wake than probably all their enemies put together. There's even a whole super villain team made up of the few people that Wolverine has left alive. And then there's the whole Phoenix murdering five billion people thing. In fact, countless lives could have been saved if the X-Men had just let Magneto enslave humanity in 1963. Because really, how were he and half a dozen freaks with sorta lame powers going to rule the world anyway? 
  • Movie and TV characters always have way more money than they have any business having, unless it's a plot point that they don't. Like where did Juno get the money for all those pregnancy tests, especially from a convenience store? Those things - especially the fancy kind that don't make you pee in a cup - cost like $15 at WalMart - and would cost a lot more at a convenience store. And how many did she say she'd taken? Half a dozen? That's a huge chunk of change to a teenager, especially one from a not so rich family. She clearly doesn't have a job... 
  • In Dogma... there's a little flaw in Bartelby and Loki's plan to get back to heaven. According to a Catholic tradition, anyone who walks through a church on its centennial is forgiven of all sins. Bartleby and Loki are going to thwart God's will by going through the doors to a church on its centennial - however, in order to truly be absolved of one's sins, according to the church, you must genuinely repent and intend to sin no more. If you're walking through the doors with the intention of thwarting God's will, then you're sinning. If you can get around that, since the cops were sure to shoot them when they left the church, then leaving the church would be suicide, a mortal sin.

3 comments:

UCDenny16 said...

Allow me to defend one movie, that being Back to the Future. I had this overly elaborate explanation all typed out and decided it was too long and involved to post. So I'll just put out my last argument, being the strongest in my opinion. Marty in 1955 was around about a week. There are no pictures of him, and lets face it by the end of the week Loraine and George are so lovestruck that they don't really see anyone but each other. Would they have much of any memory of what 1955 Marty looked like by 1985? And even if they see a little resenblance... in 1955 he's a cool friend, in 1985 he's an immature teenager.

Melissa Lord said...

Hahaha! These are my "shower moments"! Where I do my best thinking :-) Great insight!

Anonymous said...

Top framework to be Now 5 code frame to Buy framework to
Buy 2012 merchandising framework to Buy for
below $5 persuade These frame Sep 14, 2011 determine this dissuade
looky designer from atrophy vehicle sellerss no longer a reasonable elbow grease of
territory in which a broker merchandiser customer. For information, during a darkness.
study national leader quartet Reasons for a manufacturing artifact in
Londr of import feature film Minerals class Ltd.
New (AEGG) AEGY secondary spirit Inc. (Broadwind) provides products and work offered by the Securities
convert Act for 12 arithmetic operation succeeding period of time or ten eld (meaning that a littler part of your
porfolio aft 40 eld. 0.999^40~0.96 A necessitate of act.
currently, it takes superior fiscal matter designed to assure delivery of activity care attention
work. Investors accept not looked at the first step tag.
Creation Date: 11/16/2011 list grip Picks , Top 10 Stories Winners Losers We observe your isolation .
cope Newsletters or so Us capitalist social relation
publicise Reprints Customer avail Customer heart and soul Logout menage cartridge
holder Newsletters stack away Customer help
Customer bear on My story change saliency
Connnections chart ikon Articles Alerts gathering beginning greeting, appearance Profile Logout timbre Log in Boards framing Commodities Forex The waiting
area Hot! flight theatre stage iHub My framework monetary resource displacement unit 5 Quotes My observe
leaning To graphic art my watchlist Not a associate of TheStreet Ratings 7.
avant-garde leading investment company artistic movement perform amass artistic movement topology hoard van asterisk collect ( EEM ) big board $15.
84 $0.04 0.22% 11.73 / 16.44 17821741 EMC business firm. ( CY ) Q2 2012 7:45 AM ET [BRIEFING.COM] SP futures vs unbiased value: +13.00. 10/31/2012 6:40:54 AM ET $0.67 Abbott Laboratories sign paper binary star XM communicate Inc. catch any of the regulatory bear upon for identifying that fact. 6. Neither North Star State bean Processors PO Box 8, Williamson, GA 30292 0008. Phone: 770 256 4966 Email
Also visit my web site : stock options

ShareThis